2025 Montauk Highway Amagansett, NY 11930

(631) 267-6348

Temporarily closed

Menu

Appetizers

Manhattan Clam Chowder

bowl 8.50 / quart 21

Spicy Crab & Sweet Corn Bisque

bowl 10 / quart 25

New England Clam Chowder

bowl 8.50 / quart 21

Shrimp Cocktail

16
Cocktail sauce

Fried Clam Strips

15
Tartar sauce

Crab Cake

13
Gochujang aioli

Fried Local Tuna Bits*

15
Horseradish aioli

Fried Calamari

13
Gochujang aioli

Onion Rings

11
Horseradish aioli

Shellfish

Steamed Mussels

23
White wine and garlic broth, drawn butter, toast

Montauk Pearl Oysters on the Half Shell*

half dozen 13
Cocktail sauce

Steamers

32
Drawn butter, hot clam broth

Clams on the Half Shell*

half dozen 11 / dozen 19
Cocktail sauce

Salads

Add: Grilled chicken 10 / Rare grilled tuna 18 / Grilled shrimp 17 / Crab cakes (2) 14 / Fish Du Jour* MP – Add Jerk Seasoning 2

House Salad

12
Mesclun greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onion, shallot vinaigrette dressing on the side

Kale Caesar Salad

15
Rainbow chopped kale, shaved parmesan, croutons, tuscan caesar dressing

Beet & Arugula Salad

15
Baby arugula, cotija cheese, diced beet, shallot vinaigrette dressing

Spring Salad

16
Baby arugula, goat cheese, avocado, asparagus, red onion, shallot vinaigrette dressing

Entrees

All come with fries

Fish & Chips

21
Batter dipped flounder, tartar sauce

Fried Whole Belly Clams

25
Whole belly softshell clams, tartar sauce

Fried Shrimp

20
Jumbo fried shrimp, tartar sauce

Fish 'Wich

18
Batter dipped flounder on a bun, lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce

Classic Hamburger*

15 / Cheese 16

Rare Seared Tuna Sandwich*

30
Grilled on a bun, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw

Chicken Sandwich

16
Grilled on a bun, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw

Add Jerk Seasoning & Aioli 18
Marinated in Jamaican jerk seasoning, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, jerk aioli on the side

Certified Angus Beef Hot Dog

12

Chicken Tenders

13

Lobster

Lobster Salad Roll

MP
Chilled claw and knuckle meat, celery, mayo, toasted bun, coleslaw

Lobster Salad Over Salad

MP
Chilled claw and knuckle meat, celery, mayo, salad of choice

Lobster BLT

MP
Claw meat, bacon, lettuce, tomato, toasted white bread, mayo, french fries

Steamed 2 Pound Lobster

MP
Local corn, drawn butter

Sides

French fries

5

Sweet Potato Fries

6

Local Corn on the Cob

3

Coleslaw

4

Mac & Cheese

10

Extras

Gluten Free Bread

Upon request for an extra 2

Desserts

Key Lime Pie

7

Chocolate Cake

7

Peanut Butter Pie

8

Bottled Drinks

Honest Unsweetened
Iced Tea

4

Orangina

4

Topo Chico

5

Boylan Root Beer

4
regular or diet

Boylan Ginger Ale

4

Honest Apple Juice Box

2

Acqua Panna Still Water

8
1 liter

San Pellegrino Sparkling Water

8
750 ml

Fountain Drinks

Coca-Cola • Diet Coke • Sprite • Fanta Orange • Lemonade • Cranberry

3.25

Beer

Bottled and canned

Local

Ask your server about our local drafts.

Montauk Summer Ale

8

Wave Chaser IPA

8

Blue Point Toasted Lager

8

Wölffer No. 139 Cider

10

From Elsewhere

Corona Extra

7

Red Stripe

7

Kona

8

Fat Tire Amber Ale

8

Allagash White

8

Coors Light

7

Beck's Non-Alcoholic

7

Loverboy White Peach Sparkling Hard Tea

7

White Claw Black Cherry Hard Seltzer

7

Big 5 Rum Cocktail

8

Kawama Tequila Cocktail

8

Wine

Corkage fee 20

White Sangria

Pitcher 25

Prosecco

Single serve 12
Luna Nuda

Sauvignon Blanc

14 / 55
Taonga, New Zealand

Chardonnay

13 / 48
Mercer, Washington State

Pinot Grigio

11 / 40
Guinigi, Italy

Rosé

14 / 52
Soliel de Alpes, Provence, France

Pinot Noir

12 / 44
Tassajara, California

Cabernet Sauvignon

12 / 44
Tree Fort, California

Before placing your order, please inform your server if you have a food allergy.

* Consuming raw or undercooked meat, fish, shellfish and eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

A 20% auto gratuity is applied to parties of 9 or more.

Maximum 4 credit card split per table.